Policy Roadmap for Research to Improve Diagnosis
Tackling the Big Three
Focusing Research Efforts in Priority Areas
The NAM outlined a broad palette of research topics in need of further study for the field to make robust progress on this complex topic, but the report also clearly pointed the field towards early wins through an initial focus on “identifying the most common diagnostic errors, 'don’t miss' health conditions that may result in patient harm, [and] diagnostic errors that are relatively easy to address.” While the most frequent diagnostic errors are likely with common conditions such as asthma or migraine, malpractice and autopsy studies consistently find that roughly 50-80% of the serious harms resulting from missed or delayed diagnoses are linked to one of three key disease categories:
- vascular events (e.g., stroke, heart attack, pulmonary embolus)
- infections (e.g., sepsis, meningitis, appendicitis), and
- cancers (e.g., lung cancer, colon cancer, breast cancer).
We refer to these major disease categories responsible for the lion’s share of misdiagnosis-related harms as ‘The Big Three.’ The ‘Big Three’ are not evenly distributed across practice settings and patient populations—missed vascular events dominate in emergency care, missed infections are most common among children, and missed cancer diagnoses lead the way in primary care. Nevertheless, ‘Big Three’ diseases account for at least three (and up to five) of the ‘top five’ diseases across practice settings.
Table: Proportion of serious harms attributed to “The Big Three” in frontline care settings
|Clinical Settings||Vascular Events||Infections||Cancers||Total|
|Adult Primary Care||~12%||~8%||~60%||~80%|
It is noteworthy that causes (and therefore solutions) likely differ substantially across the ‘Big Three.’ The Table below identifies one key disease example for each of the ‘Big Three’ categories.
Table: Exemplars from each “Big Three” category with diagnostic error causes and possible solutions
|Misdiagnosis||Principal Cause||Solution(s) in Need of Further Research|
|Stroke||No specialty expertise||Telemedicine & device-based decision support|
|Sepsis||Overwhelmed by data||Big data visual analytics & machine learning algorithms|
|Lung Cancer||Results not communicated||Direct-to-patient reports & EHR triggers to close loops|
More from the SIDM Policy Roadmap:
Help us create a world where no patients are harmed by diagnostic error. Get involved with the Society to Improve Diagnosis in Medicine (SIDM) today.